Housing market dynamics: Navigating the challenges and opportunities ahead

Today's housing market is a dynamic, multifaceted landscape, presenting challenges and opportunities. In my recent discussion with Willy Walker on the Walker Webcast, I discussed several critical aspects of the current market. We covered key trends and data points shaping our outlook.

Current state of the housing market

In many respects, the housing market is experiencing a slow grind. New construction for single-family homes has shown resilience despite rising interest rates. However, sustaining the sales pace is becoming more challenging. We’re seeing more incentives entering the market as affordability concerns grow. The existing home market is experiencing rising inventories, which is beneficial for transactions but leads to price deceleration as competition increases.

The multifamily sector is also intriguing. There is a combination of a significant supply close to completion and a promising drop-off in new starts. This might lead to a need for more supply in the multifamily shelter category by late 2025 or early 2026, as Gen Z forms new households and requires more multifamily housing options.

The impact of interest rates and affordability

High interest rates are a significant factor influencing the market today. Mortgage rates of 6.5 percent or above put substantial downward pressure on purchase activity. However, even small reductions in rates can significantly impact affordability.

The "lock-in effect," where many homeowners hold onto low-rate mortgages obtained during the pandemic, disincentivizes movement within the market. Assuming rates were to fall to 5.5 percent, we would expect it to stimulate activity and encourage more transactions.

Affordability remains a significant challenge, with rising interest rates and increasing home prices. The market has seen record cash purchases, particularly at the lower end of the price spectrum. The higher end remains relatively strong. Sellers often hold out for peak pricing seen during the pandemic, adding another layer of complexity.

Single-family rental vs. homeownership

Our analysis of single-family rentals (SFR) versus homeownership revealed a growing gap. Rentals are increasingly attractive. Renting a new build-for-rent home costs about 9 percent less than owning a similar property in various metropolitan areas. We expect this gap to widen slightly due to rising costs associated with homeownership, such as homeowners insurance, higher property taxes, and utilities. In comparison, renting an apartment is nearly 30 percent more affordable than purchasing a home.However, comparing the two asset classes is not as compelling given the comparison is really apples to oranges. Nevertheless, it could create more friction, leading to a modest increase in demand for apartment rentals.

Public vs. private builders market share

Publicly traded home builders have dramatically increased their market share over private builders. They now hold over 50 percent of the market compared to less than 10 percent in the early 1990s. This shift is mainly due to advantages in capital and scale that allow public builders to secure better terms for building materials and land purchases. However, private builders in dominant regional markets with strong reputations continue to thrive despite these challenges.

Land and regulatory challenges

Land prices and regulatory hurdles remain significant obstacles for builders. The land market is tight, and approvals from municipalities and utility hookups are becoming increasingly difficult to secure. Unlike other materials, land prices did not come under pressure during the pandemic and have continued to rise. Regulatory changes under the current administration also add to the burden, particularly for private builders.

Multifamily market and rent growth

The multifamily market is experiencing mixed dynamics. Certain regions face oversupply and others see stability. Some areas are supply-laden and face competitive pressures. On the other hand, regions like the Pacific Northwest, West, Midwest and Northeast benefit from a lack of new development, allowing for stable to higher rent rates. Overall, we’ve adjusted our rent growth expectations slightly upward, reflecting a more resilient market than initially anticipated.

Long-term housing market outlook

Looking ahead, the need for more rental stock remains evident. Our updated population and household growth forecasts show an acceleration, driven in part by immigration. Young adults leaving home at higher rates than expected also contribute to this trend. Multifamily housing will likely be the biggest beneficiary of this growth, as new households often start in rental properties.

Opportunities in the build-for-rent (BFR) market

The build-for-rent market continues to present significant opportunities. Many potential homebuyers prefer new homes and the single-family living experience. While the high cost of capital poses challenges, there is potential for deeper-pocket investors to capitalize on this market. The rental cash flow model is compelling, offering continuity and stability for investors.

Potential for technological innovations

Technological innovations like 3D printing and modular building hold promise. However, they are still in the early stages and have not yet significantly impacted the housing market. However, the manufactured housing industry continues to offer factory-built homes that could help address affordability challenges.

Navigate challenges and find opportunities with Walker & Dunlop

The housing market is a complex and evolving environment. High interest rates and affordability concerns pose challenges. However, there are significant opportunities in the rental and build-for-rent sectors. By understanding these dynamics and staying informed, stakeholders can navigate the market effectively and capitalize on emerging trends.

To learn more about what’s happening in the market and where opportunities exist, attend the Annual Zelman Housing Summit on September 12 & 13 at the InterContinental Hotel in Boston. Register today.

‍